Carnivale has my favorite style of character division. Since the show is composed of two parallel story lines, the cast of characters is roughly divided in half, as I like to refer to it the Nick
Stahl half and the Clancy Brown half. This also means that the run time of the show is also halved, which is perfect for impatient people like me.
Nick Stahl is the reason I started watching Carnivale. I was riding high of my viewing of Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines, which starred Mr Stahl as John Connor. The first adds for Canivale, the Season 1 package cover, hit the streets almost simultaneously, and my interest was piqued. It took until the 2004 DVD release, a Christmas present, for me to see a second of the show, but until then I followed it loosely via reviews, primarily those published in Entertainment Weekly (I mention this so that those reading know that I was not overcome by fits of research prior to asking for a sight-unseen television box set for a Christmas present.) I viewed the entire first season and then shelved the show, relatively underwhelmed. This let down feeling also went along with season 2, which I was watching on air concurrently in January 2005. The best thing I can say about what that did for me was get me into Deadwood, which was re-running the first season at the time. These episodes would lead me to my favorite show of all time, Deadwood. I did however drop out of viewing Carnivale season 2 around the fourth episode, so the first ever show I watched on HBO was officially discarded. During a what would become to be routine home invasion in 2006, the set was stolen. and I never gave the show a thought after that.
I proceeded to do something odd for my birthday in 2007. I had asked for Season 2 of Carnivale on a whim, got it, and then asked for a Season 1 replacement Christmas. I re-watched Season 1 over January 2008, but inexplicably stopped 11 episodes in when my mother retired that same month around that same time.
Today I had cause to open the show up again. After some Rome viewings a few days back, I decided that my Winter should be made up of finishing my cancelled HBO shows, namely, Deadwood and Carnivale. SInce Carnivale is a show only I am into in this household, I am using my time during the day to consume the mythology choked show. Like I said earlier, the show is divided into two halves. The Nick Stahl half does battle against the Clancy Brown half. Nick Stahl plays an isolated southwest kid whom we meet burying his mother. A bulldozer driven by the bank destroys his home, and a traveling Carnival takes him on as help. We meet Clancy Brown, a pious minister who begins to be tormented by his past and his own internal demon. Over the course of season 1, it becomes apparent that a battle between these two men who have never met is imminent, with the Nick Stahl, or Ben Hawkins, as good and Clancy Brown, or Brother Justin Crowe, as evil. It also becomes clear that the man who runs the Carnival had the same relationship with Ben's father, the elusive Henry Scudder. Set against the biblical backdrop of the 1930s dust bowl, Carnivale is as cryptic as they come but lent an air of urgency via setting and the music, which sounds lifted from the horror genre, with a touch of religious grandeur added to give a certain weight to it.
I found episodes eleven and twelve of season 1 very rewarding, and now plan on diving head-first into the second, final season. I seem to always be doing this, getting into shows that I know full well end too soon. I wonder what that says about me psychologically, a question I plan to leave to the professionals. It does show, evident to anyone, that the premium cable networks need to give their shows more of a chance.